Window for December Rate Cut Still Open, But ...

We were in the camp that the Federal Reserve (Fed) should have reduced interest rates during the first half of the year, taking advantage of the underlying disinflationary path during that period. Furthermore, we think the disinflationary path is still in motion today and will continue during the next several quarters, helped by a continuous slowdown in shelter prices. However, the prospects for further rate cuts past December does not look that promising, especially if the US economy starts to strengthen during the first half of the year, as we expect, and/or there is any truth to the tariff refund President Donald Trump has been promoting in social media.

Although it is true that inflation increased everywhere in the world as the global economy started to reopen after the pandemic closures, the stickiness and the perseverance of inflation in the US was supported, during both the Trump and Joseph Biden administrations, by the monumental income transfers the federal government made to individuals and firms during that period. This was a perfect storm, with supply chain issues affecting supply and pushing prices higher at the same time that aggregate demand expanded as Americans started to spend the excess savings accumulated during the pandemic.

Disposable income graph

Today’s tariff-driven increase in inflation is expected to be a one-off increase in prices that will have a very short runway, as Americans will have to make tough decisions and cut other expenditures in order to buy those goods affected by the increase in tariffs and/or adjust consumer behavior so as to minimize the impact of these tariffs on individual and family budgets.

However, if the Trump administration goes forward with this idea of sending a $2,000 check to Americans earning less than $100k (according to recent news) to help them confront higher prices due to tariffs and/or to compensate them for the increase in health care costs, then all bets are off for inflation as well as for interest rates, as the Federal Reserve will have to stop lowering interest rates and may even have to point to higher interest rates in the not so distant future.

Fiscal deficit graph

But the $2,000 check is not only bad in terms of inflation as well as interest rates, it is even more negative for the US’s fiscal and debt path, as shown by the Congressional Budget Office estimate in the graph above. That is, for the first time in decades, Republicans have agreed to increase taxes, and tax revenues are flowing at a rate of ~$350 billion per year. However, these tax revenue flows are not going to be permanent. If, as the Trump administration argues, these tariffs are going to bring back production to the US, then this means that, over time, these tariff revenues are going to come down compared to what is being raised today. Thus, these extra tax revenues should be used to lower the fiscal deficit rather than given back to consumers.