Bonds Starting to Offer More Diversification

Key Takeaways

  • Bonds, once viewed as a reliable hedge against risk, took on the role of “risk accelerator” since 2021 as inflation shifted traditional stock/bond correlations from negative to positive. This trend is now showing signs of a reversal.
  • As inflation has slowed in recent years, it has also become less volatile. With anticipation of further Fed easing and likely expansion of the central bank’s balance sheet, Russ believes that bonds could once again fill the role of a traditional portfolio diversifier.

For the better part of 20 years bonds offered little yield but effective diversification. From the aftermath of the internet bubble through the pandemic, stock/bond correlations were consistently negative, making a Treasury bond an effective portfolio hedge.

Unfortunately, starting in 2021 that relationship abruptly shifted. A sharp and abrupt rise in inflation turned bonds from a risk mitigant to a risk accelerator. However, that dynamic may be in the process of changing, suggesting that bonds may once again start to provide some portfolio diversification.

Inflation elevated, but less volatile

As I’ve discussed in previous blogs, shifting stock/bond correlations marked a paradigm shift relative to the 2000-2020 period. What changed? Inflation. The re-emergence of inflation fundamentally shifted stock/bond correlations as higher prices became as much of a risk to markets as slowing growth.

Today, while inflation remains above the Fed’s 2% target, it has slowed dramatically, with most measures of core inflation running between 2.5% and 3.0%. This moderation has led to some mean reversion in stock/bond correlations. For much of the past two years, stocks and bonds have traded with a correlation close to zero, suggesting no statistically significant pattern in how they trade relative to each other. Most recently the correlation has reverted to slightly negative (see Chart 1).

Correlation of bond and equity returns

Correlation of bond and equity returns (1-year rolling)

What may be changing? Inflation remains elevated but is becoming less volatile. Historically, this has been important for how stocks and bonds trade. In other words, it is not just the level of inflation that influences investor behavior but also the stability, or lack thereof, of inflation.