What’s Next for US Small-Caps in 2026?

Miles Lewis: We believe that both small-cap quality and value are poised for meaningful rebounds in 2026. 2025’s returns, particularly since the April lows, have been driven primarily by lower quality, speculative stocks and just about anything that is an obvious beneficiary of the artificial intelligence (AI) boom, even those companies with no current revenues, such as one company with a US$15 billion market value—and no revenue! Low quality cycles tend to last about 12 months on average, suggesting that a regime shift in 2026 is likely.

Furthermore, more “traditional” businesses models—those that have healthy margins, generate free cash flow, grow modestly, and have strong, self-funding balance sheets that also trade at attractive valuations (i.e., quality value stocks) should recapture the interest of investors as the junk rally fizzles. Fitting this narrative, we see businesses in sectors such as consumer staples and in industries like packaging, business services, and insurance doing well. We also see the AI theme broadening from (mostly) capital expenditure (capex) related models to companies that can commercialize AI applications to grow their businesses and/or companies—which will see margin improvement by leveraging AI tools.

We also see one development that will surprise investors in 2026: Small-caps will likely outperform! The long, dark winter of small-cap underperformance has been exhaustively documented and is well understood. We think 2026 could be the year that small-caps reassert themselves.

Importantly, we see a path to this outperformance in at least two ways: In one scenario, the economy will have continued and accelerating strength in 2026, in part driven by stimulus coming from Washington that could benefit both businesses and consumers, particularly those in the lower half of the income distribution. Should this occur, we’d likely see more widespread economic growth, benefiting a broader array of industries from banks (thanks to loan growth and healthy credit) to select areas in industrials (due to onshoring and solid general growth) and consumer discretionary. The earnings growth of small-caps, already expected to beat large-caps in 2026, would likely accelerate further. AI would no longer be the only growth game in town! In this scenario, it’s likely we see a broadening of US equity market returns, in stark contrast to the unprecedented narrow market leadership of the last few years. Historically, when this happens, small-caps have beaten large-caps most of the time and have done so by healthy margins.

The other scenario, which is less rosy, is that the AI bubble begins to deflate – or worse, bursts. In fact, we could see the ‘Mag 7’ become the ‘Lag 7’. If this were to happen, we’re likely to see a period of poor performance across all style and market cap spectrums. But it’s also quite plausible that small-caps, having lagged meaningfully already and sporting far less demanding valuations, fall less, perhaps much less. While that may sound farfetched, this is exactly what happened when the tech bubble burst in 2000.

Based on our conversations with CEOs and CFOs across a variety of industries, the former scenario seems more likely, and that’s our hope. But narratives, as well as fundamentals, can change quickly and unexpectedly at times of excess. We aim to be prepared to capitalize on opportunities in either scenario.