The Primary Rationale for the Gold Bull’s Run is Persistent Apathy

The near-perfect timing of gold breaking through $5,000 while silver sliced through $100 has grabbed the market’s attention. In explaining how gold got so high, and how it could go higher, gold bulls point to general currency debasement, central bank accumulation and a geopolitical landscape that includes outright or potential regime change in Iran, Venezuela, Cuba and Greenland. In the very near-term, some strategists are worried about a government shutdown this week, the odds of which have jumped to 81% from as low as 9% a few days ago, according to Polymarket.

Gold’s rally, beyond the psychologically critical $5,000 level, has been all the more impressive because, at least since October, it has occurred amid a backdrop of gently rising interest rates. Just before Halloween, the 10-year Treasury Note yielded 3.95%. For whatever reason, be it fiscal profligacy, the “4-handle” recently reported on GDP growth, or the sheer amount of debt being issued by the federal government, that security’s rate has drifted up to 4.22%. From an opportunity cost perspective, whereby higher rates tend to hinder metals prices, gold’s surge amid the bond market’s action is impressive.

But we think any move to $6,000, or who-knows-where, will be predicated on investors changing their apathetic ways.

Consider this: nearly 100% of the exchange-traded product industry’s gold and gold mining-related products are held in the top 30 funds, which collectively have assets under management of $365 billion. While that may sound like a big number, that sum is only equal to the market capitalization of Procter & Gamble, the 26th-largest member of the S&P 500. Nvidia’s market capitalization is $4.56 trillion.

The metal and the miners make appearances here and there in some of their other funds, but to this day, there is no such thing as The Vanguard Gold Fund.