More on the Middle East

The war in Iran is approaching the two-week mark. What started as a focused set of sorties has broadened into something more durable and dangerous. Iran is not Venezuela.

It has been a volatile interval on the ground in the Middle East, and in the financial markets. Here is some background on how we are thinking about the economic consequences of the hostilities.

  • We are experiencing a significant energy shock. The Strait of Hormuz, a narrow artery through which a substantial fraction of the world’s oil passes, is essentially closed. Iran is able to imperil transit effectively with inexpensive mines and drones, discouraging passage and raising maritime insurance rates. It will be difficult, if not impossible, to neutralize this threat through aerial attacks alone. Using naval escorts to clear a path may not be that effective, and raises the risk of military casualties.

    Alternative channels like pipelines cannot handle the same level of output, and cannot move commodities other than oil. With storage capacity stretched, crude production has slowed; oil producing countries in the Middle East are seeing reduced export revenues. Once stopped, restarting production will take time.

chart-1-1999-vs-2005

Oil prices have risen significantly, and they have been extremely volatile. The downstream impacts of this on fuel costs for consumers, factories and transportation around the world are already being felt. Derivatives from oil refining are used in a range of products, including fertilizer. Diminished energy and aluminum supplies may impair factories in a number of countries, extending the disruption to a wide range of products. Shipping costs are up sharply. The inflation that will ensue could be broader and deeper than anticipated.

Damage to critical infrastructure in the region has been limited, but could easily expand. If a key production facility or energy terminal is attacked, energy prices could ascend sharply. This is among the many non-linearities surrounding the situation.

To compensate for dwindling imports, several nations have announced releases from strategic petroleum reserves, but using stocks to offset flows is a temporary solution at best. Some countries, like India, have very modest reserves, which will not provide much of a buffer.

Other nations are starting to limit exports, extending distortions in the market. Rationing is also being employed in some places. Government support for energy consumers or temporary reductions in fuel taxes will add to fiscal deficits, and may place pressure on bond or currency markets in the countries that apply them.

The impairment of the energy supply chain is not as substantial as the broad shock produced by the pandemic. But the 2020 experience illustrates how consequences can radiate from an epicenter.

While the world is much less petroleum-dependent than it once was, we’re being reminded that no other commodity is as central to economic activity…and daily life.

hopes for a quick resolution